Search Here

Paramount Pictures emerged victorious in a copyright lawsuit related to the iconic film franchise, "Top Gun."

The dispute centered on whether the studio breached copyright laws by moving forward with the sequel without renegotiating licensing agreements.

However, US District Judge Percy Anderson ruled in favor of Paramount, dismissing the case and affirming that the sequel, "Top Gun: Maverick," did not infringe upon the original work's copyright (via The Hollywood Reporter).

'Top Gun' Copyright Lawsuit

The lawsuit, filed in 2022, was initiated by the heirs of Ehud Yonay, the author of a 1983 magazine article that inspired the first "Top Gun" movie. They argued that Paramount should have obtained a new license before proceeding with the sequel.

Despite their claims, the court found significant differences between the article and the film, stating that copyright law does not protect factual elements such as plot and setting. The judge stated copyright law does not protect factual elements, common plot themes, or specific dialogue.

According to court documents, Paramount contended that it did not require a new license as the original article was nonfiction and lacked substantial similarity to the blockbuster film. Judge Anderson concurred, emphasizing that factual elements are exempt from copyright protection.

"We are pleased that the court recognized that plaintiffs' claims were completely without merit," Paramount said in a statement.

The ruling is a significant victory for Paramount, clearing the way for future installments in the "Top Gun" franchise. A Paramount spokesperson expressed satisfaction with the outcome, stating, "We are pleased that the court recognized that plaintiffs' claims were completely without merit."

Paramount Win Sets Precedent for Copyright Disputes

Furthermore, the decision sets a precedent for copyright disputes involving sequels based on source material. It underscores the importance of analyzing substantial similarity and protecting factual elements in such cases.

This legal resolution comes as Paramount prepares for potential future projects within the franchise. With a third film in talks and the massive success of "Top Gun: Maverick," which grossed $1.5 billion globally, the studio can now proceed without the legal impediments posed by the lawsuit.