Justin Bieber and Usher are currently facing a $10 million lawsuit. Accordingly the lawsuit in 2013 has been revived by the 4th U.S Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond, Virginia.
Reuter has it reported via CBSNews stating that the Court of Appeals had a consentaneous decision to reinstate the complaint filed by De Rico (also known as Devin Copeland) and Overton against Justin Bieber and Usher in 2013. In view of the previous court decision, it had been mentioned that the findings were based on its significant differences. However, this time the court would focus on the similarties between the first "Somebody to Love" (written in 2008 by Copeland and Overton) and Bieber's version in 2010.
In the said report, Circuit Judge Pamela Harris quoted saying after listening to the Copeland song and Bieber and Usher's, "we conclude that their choruses are similar enough and also significant enough that a reasonable jury could find the songs intrinsically similar."
If readers' memory serves them right, Bieber's album "My World 2.0" had been under controversy in 2013 because the single had a very striking resemblance to another song of the same title. However, the case was dismissed in 2014.
In another report of ArtsBeat NYTimes, Critic Judge Pamela Harries said that there was no bearing that genre of Bieber and Usher's versions were dance pop with a hint of electronica whilst the complainants' was R&B. According to Copeland and Overton that Usher did listen to their song because it was presented to him by the plaintiff's music scout. Usher allegedly told Bieber about the song, thus it was included in his 2010 "My World 2.0" album. The remix of that song, with Usher being featured, has landed no 15 on Billboard Charts later in 2010.
Aside from Bieber and Usher, Mirror UK mentioned other names of companies included in the lawsuit. Devin and Mareio also sued Sony Corp's Sony/ATV Music Publishing and Vivendi SA's Universal Music Publishing Group.
Justin Bieber and Usher are now looking for a credible lawyer to defend them in this $10 million copyright lawsuit.
Join the Conversation